In today’s world, Western horse tack sets are widely popular among riders, as they play a key role in both the horse’s comfort and riding performance. A well-made tack set enhances the riding experience by aligning with the horse’s movement and style. Typically, a Western tack set includes a headstall, breast collar, saddle, saddle pad, wither strap, spur strap, and reins—each component serving an important function in Western horseback riding. The quality of the tack is essential not just for durability, but also for ensuring the horse's comfort during rides. In this blog, we will explore the advantages and disadvantages of machine-made and handcrafted Western horse tack sets:
What is Machine-Made Western Tack?
Machine-made Western tack is produced using automated tools and factory processes, allowing for the mass production of saddles, bridles, breast collars, and other tack components. These items are typically cut, stitched, and assembled by machines with minimal human intervention. As a result, production is fast, consistent, and scalable.
Materials Commonly Used:
Machine-made tack often uses synthetic materials like nylon, biothane, or lower to mid-grade leather. Hardware may be made from stainless steel, nickel-plated metal, or other cost-effective options. Decorative elements, if included, are usually stamped or printed.
Price Range and Availability:
Machine-made tack is widely available both online and in large tack stores. It’s typically priced on the lower end of the spectrum, making it a popular choice for beginner riders, casual use, or as a budget-friendly backup, depending on the item and brand.
Shop Our Handcrafted Western Horse Tack Set
What Is Handcrafted Western Tack?
Handcrafted Western tack is created by skilled artisans who use traditional techniques such as hand-cutting, hand-tooling, and hand-stitching. Each piece is often made in small batches or as one-of-a-kind, with special attention given to detail, fit, and finish.
Materials Often Used:
High-quality leather—such as full-grain or vegetable-tanned hide—is the hallmark of handcrafted tack. Hardware is usually solid brass, stainless steel, or other durable, long-lasting metals. Handcrafted pieces often feature detailed tooling, custom carving, and hand-applied finishes.
Price Range and Where It’s Typically Sold:
Handcrafted tack is typically sold through specialty retailers, independent leatherworkers, artisan markets, or custom saddle makers. Prices reflect the time and skill involved, depending on the complexity and materials used.
Key Difference to Consider
1. Quality and Craftsmanship
The quality and craftsmanship of both machine-made and handcrafted Western horse tack sets largely depend on the materials and hardware used. This aspect is essential not only for the rider’s performance but also for the horse’s comfort and safety.
Leather remains one of the most popular and trusted materials in the market due to its durability and longevity, provided it is properly cared for. It is also a craft-friendly material, especially suitable for hand tooling and carving. However, the overall craftsmanship also depends on the stitching, finishing, and detailing. Handcrafted tack typically excels in these areas, showcasing skilled workmanship and attention to detail, while machine-made tack tends to offer consistency and uniformity.
2. Durability and Longevity
The choice of material plays a crucial role in the durability and longevity of a tack set. Various materials are available in the market, including leather, synthetic leather, and biothane. Among these, leather stands out as the most durable and long-lasting option when properly maintained.
That said, not all leather is created equal. The quality can vary widely, and one of the most premium options is Argentine cow leather. Known for its strength, smooth texture, and excellent aging properties, it is a preferred choice among riders who value both performance and appearance.
If you want to learn more about Argentine cow leather, Read This Article.
3. Fit and Function
Machine-made tack is built to general measurements and may not suit every horse equally. Fit issues can lead to discomfort or reduced performance. Handcrafted tack can be customized to the horse’s build and the rider’s needs, offering a more precise fit. This often translates to better weight distribution, fewer pressure points, and increased comfort for the horse, especially during long rides or heavy use.
4. Aesthetic Appeal
If you’re looking for personality and artistry, handcrafted tack stands out. From floral tooling to custom dye work and conchos, handcrafted sets are often made to reflect the rider’s style. Machine-made tack tends to have a more uniform, utilitarian look. While some options include decorative stamping or color choices, they rarely match the detail and richness of hand-tooling.
5. Cost and Value
Machine-made tack is more affordable upfront, making it a good choice for beginners or riders on a tight budget. However, it may need to be replaced more often. Handcrafted tack requires a higher initial investment but offers long-term value through durability, comfort, and even resale potential. Some handcrafted brands hold value well due to their reputation, especially when properly maintained.
When to Choose Machine-Made vs Handcrafted Tack Set
When to Choose Machine-Made Tack
1. You’re new to riding
If you're just getting started with Western riding, a machine-made tack set can be a sensible first step. It allows you to try different styles and gear types without a large financial commitment. This way, you can learn what works best for you and your horse before investing in more expensive, long-term equipment.
2. You're on a tight budget
Machine-made tack is ideal for riders or horse owners who need to stay within a strict budget. You can typically find complete tack sets at a fraction of the cost of handcrafted ones. While you may compromise on certain materials or custom features, you’ll still get gear that is functional and safe for everyday use.
3. It’s for occasional or light use
If you only ride a few times a month or need a tack set for short trail rides, training sessions, or riding lessons, a machine-made option is usually sufficient. It meets basic performance needs without requiring the higher investment or maintenance routine that handcrafted sets demand.
4. You’re outfitting multiple horses or a riding program
Barns with lesson programs, ranches with working horses, or any setup with multiple horses may find machine-made tack more practical. It’s easier to replace, and standardized sizes make it more versatile. You can keep spare tack on hand without overextending your budget.
Explore Our Western Saddle Collection
When to Choose Handcrafted Tack
1. You ride frequently or professionally
For riders who spend long hours in the saddle—whether for work, training, or competition—comfort and durability become essential. Handcrafted tack is designed to withstand heavy use and is often better suited to the rigors of regular riding. The attention to detail in construction also means better weight distribution and fewer pressure points on your horse.
2. You want long-term value
While the initial cost is higher, handcrafted tack is built to last, sometimes decades with proper care. The stitching, leather quality, and hardware are designed for longevity, making it a smarter investment over time. Many riders find that a well-maintained handcrafted set actually becomes more comfortable and attractive with age.
3. Your horse has specific fitting needs
Not all horses fit neatly into standard sizes. Horses with high withers, short backs, or muscular builds may benefit from tack that is shaped and adjusted specifically for them. Handcrafted sets often allow for such customization, improving both the horse’s comfort and the rider’s control.
4. You value detail and craftsmanship
If aesthetics matter to you—whether you're competing, performing, or simply enjoy riding in something unique—handcrafted tack offers beauty that machine-made gear can’t match. From floral tooling to basket weave patterns and custom color finishes, handcrafted pieces are often true works of art.
5. It’s for show or competition
In the show ring, presentation matters. Handcrafted tack sets are often chosen for their visual appeal and ability to complement the rider’s outfit and the horse’s appearance. High-quality leather, antique or engraved conchos, and clean tooling can set you apart and reflect a higher level of professionalism.
Choose MOUSM
If you find a Western tack set collection, MOUSM is a great place to visit for. Here, you'll find a wide range of equestrian products, including headstalls, breast collars, wither and spur straps, bronc halters, saddles, saddle pads, bosals, as well as home décor and fashion accessories etc. Every piece is crafted from genuine Argentine cowhide leather and meticulously handmade by skilled artisans. Each design showcases exceptional craftsmanship, featuring intricate hand tooling, striking acid wash finishes, and eye-catching stonework.
Equipped with premium-quality studs, sparkling stones, and elegant conchos, these products are built to offer both durability and long-lasting performance. Their sturdy construction ensures they can handle the rigors of Western riding while maintaining their stylish appeal.
Perfect for Western riding, rodeo events, equestrian shows, and everyday wear, MOUSM pieces not only complement your gear with confidence but also add a distinctive and fashionable flair to your collection. Whether you’re in the arena or on the trail, these accessories combine functionality with stunning design, reflecting your passion for riding and your appreciation for quality craftsmanship. Shop Once! and Grab Amazing Deals and Discounts
